Profile Menu
Shopping Cary 0 Cart
location_on Muskego, WI
Open   until 9 PM

SHOP BAKING INGREDIENTS

  • Baking Mixes

    Baking Mixes

  • Frosting & Decorations

    Frosting & Decorations

  • Candies, Chips & Bark

    Candies, Chips & Bark

  • Spices

    Spices

  • Sugar & Sweeteners

    Sugar & Sweeteners

  • Flour & Meals

    Flour & Meals

  • Oils

    Oils

    • SHOP BAKEWARE

  • Cake Pans

    Cake Pans
  • Cookie Cutters

    Cookie Cutters
  • Cookie Sheets

    Cookie Sheets
  • Decorating Tools

    Decorating Tools
  • Muffin Pans

    Muffin Pans
  • Pie Pans

    Pie Pans
  • Bread Pans

    Bread Pans
  • Baking Dishes

    Baking Dishes
  • Baking Tools & Gadgets

    Baking Tools & Gadgets

    • SHOP ALL BAKING

    Refinements

    close
    Clear filters
    Muskego edit
    Clear filters
    Baking Mixes (54)
    Candies, Chips & Bark (26)
    Flour & Meals (10)
    Frosting & Decorations (40)
    Oils (29)
    Salt & Spices (31)
    Sugar & Sweeteners (28)
    Items To View
    • Original Soybean and Peanut Blend Frying Oil
      $19.99 - $49.99
      Butler’s Pantry Original Soybean and Peanut Blend Frying Oil
      Original Soybean and Peanut Blend Frying Oil
      Butler’s Pantry Original Soybean and Peanut Blend Frying Oil
      $19.99 - $49.99
    • All-Vegetable Shortening
      $8.78
      CRISCO All-Vegetable Shortening
      All-Vegetable Shortening
      CRISCO All-Vegetable Shortening
      $8.78
    • 24 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $8.49
      From the Pantry 24 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      24 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      From the Pantry 24 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $8.49
    • Moist Supreme 15.25 oz Premium Dark Chocolate Cake Mix
      $1.99
      Pillsbury Moist Supreme 15.25 oz Premium Dark Chocolate Cake Mix
      Moist Supreme 15.25 oz Premium Dark Chocolate Cake Mix
      Pillsbury Moist Supreme 15.25 oz Premium Dark Chocolate Cake Mix
      $1.99
    • 100% Peanut Oil
      $25.99 - $69.99
      Butler’s Pantry 100% Peanut Oil
      100% Peanut Oil
      Butler’s Pantry 100% Peanut Oil
      $25.99 - $69.99
    • 48 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $15.99
      Fleet Farm 48 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      48 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      Fleet Farm 48 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $15.99
    • 24 oz Chocolate Flavored Coating Bar
      $4.89
      Eillien’s 24 oz Chocolate Flavored Coating Bar
      24 oz Chocolate Flavored Coating Bar
      Eillien’s 24 oz Chocolate Flavored Coating Bar
      $4.89
    • 24 oz Vanilla Flavored Coating Bar
      $4.89
      Eillien’s 24 oz Vanilla Flavored Coating Bar
      24 oz Vanilla Flavored Coating Bar
      Eillien’s 24 oz Vanilla Flavored Coating Bar
      $4.89
    • 32 oz Pure Maple Syrup
      $18.49
      Wild Country 32 oz Pure Maple Syrup
      32 oz Pure Maple Syrup
      Wild Country 32 oz Pure Maple Syrup
      $18.49
    • 16 oz Deluxe Caramels
      $4.39
      Fleet Farm 16 oz Deluxe Caramels
      16 oz Deluxe Caramels
      Fleet Farm 16 oz Deluxe Caramels
      $4.39
    • Yeast, Instant Dry, Quick Rise Original 0.75 Oz.
      $2.19
      Red Star Yeast, Instant Dry, Quick Rise Original 0.75 Oz.
      Yeast, Instant Dry, Quick Rise Original 0.75 Oz.
      Red Star Yeast, Instant Dry, Quick Rise Original 0.75 Oz.
      $2.19
    • 16 oz Cinnamon Imperials
      $4.99
      Fleet Farm 16 oz Cinnamon Imperials
      16 oz Cinnamon Imperials
      Fleet Farm 16 oz Cinnamon Imperials
      $4.99
    • 12 oz Full Flavor Molasses
      $4.99
      BRER RABBIT 12 oz Full Flavor Molasses
      12 oz Full Flavor Molasses
      BRER RABBIT 12 oz Full Flavor Molasses
      $4.99
    • 48 oz Milk Chocolate Chips
      $15.99
      Fleet Farm 48 oz Milk Chocolate Chips
      48 oz Milk Chocolate Chips
      Fleet Farm 48 oz Milk Chocolate Chips
      $15.99
    • 4 lb Pure Granulated Sugar
      $3.69
      Essential EVERYDAY 4 lb Pure Granulated Sugar
      4 lb Pure Granulated Sugar
      Essential EVERYDAY 4 lb Pure Granulated Sugar
      $3.69
    • 10 oz Jet-Puffed Miniature Marshmallows
      $1.89
      JET-PUFFED 10 oz Jet-Puffed Miniature Marshmallows
      10 oz Jet-Puffed Miniature Marshmallows
      JET-PUFFED 10 oz Jet-Puffed Miniature Marshmallows
      $1.89
    • 12 oz Mild Flavor Molasses
      $4.99
      BRER RABBIT 12 oz Mild Flavor Molasses
      12 oz Mild Flavor Molasses
      BRER RABBIT 12 oz Mild Flavor Molasses
      $4.99
    • 24 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $8.49
      Fleet Farm 24 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      24 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      Fleet Farm 24 oz Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $8.49
    • 64 oz 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour
      $14.99
      BOB’S RED MILL 64 oz 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour
      64 oz 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour
      BOB’S RED MILL 64 oz 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour
      $14.99
    • 12 oz Jet-Puffed Marshmallows
      $1.99 SALE
      Reg. $2.29
      JET-PUFFED 12 oz Jet-Puffed Marshmallows
      12 oz Jet-Puffed Marshmallows
      JET-PUFFED 12 oz Jet-Puffed Marshmallows
      $1.99 SALE
      Reg. $2.29
    • 16.75 oz Confetti Angel Food Cake Mix
      $3.99
      Betty Crocker 16.75 oz Confetti Angel Food Cake Mix
      16.75 oz Confetti Angel Food Cake Mix
      Betty Crocker 16.75 oz Confetti Angel Food Cake Mix
      $3.99
    • 11 oz Butterscotch Flavored Morsels
      $5.79
      Nestle Toll House 11 oz Butterscotch Flavored Morsels
      11 oz Butterscotch Flavored Morsels
      Nestle Toll House 11 oz Butterscotch Flavored Morsels
      $5.79
    • 32 oz Pure Light Brown Sugar
      $2.39
      Essential EVERYDAY 32 oz Pure Light Brown Sugar
      32 oz Pure Light Brown Sugar
      Essential EVERYDAY 32 oz Pure Light Brown Sugar
      $2.39
    • 12 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $4.99
      Fleet Farm 12 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      12 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      Fleet Farm 12 oz Mini Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
      $4.99
    Close Navigation